Thursday, July 30, 2009

Dilbert's "Dan the Illogical Scientist"

Dilbert's 'Dan the Illogical Scientist'

Pasteur, Heisenberg, Pauli, and Gödel

Louis Pasteur was a "chemist, founder of physio-chemistry, father of bacteriology, inventor of bio-therapeuties."
Pasteur's faith was as genuine as his science. In his panegyric of Littré, whose fauteuil he took, he said:
Happy the man who bears within him a divinity, an ideal of beauty and obeys it; and ideal of art, and ideal of science, an ideal of country, and ideal of the virtues of the Gospel.
These words are graven above his tomb in the Institut Pasteur. In his address Pasteur said further "These are the living springs of great thoughts and great actions. Everything grows clear in the reflections from the Infinite". Some of his letters to his children breathe profound simple piety. He declared "The more I know, the more nearly is my faith that of the Breton peasant. Could I but know all I would have the faith of a Breton peasant woman." What he could not above all understand is the failure of scientists to recognize the demonstration of the existence of the Creator that there is in the world around us. He died with his rosary in his hand, after listening to the life of St. Vincent de Paul which he had asked to have read to him, because he thought that his work like that of St. Vincent would do much to save suffering children.

Catholic Encyclopedia "Louis Pasteur"

Thus knowledge of God and his creation is much clearer and more easily obtained through faith than through natural reason:
There is a great difference between Christian philosophy and human wisdom. The latter, guided solely by the light of nature, advances slowly by reasoning on sensible objects and effects, and only after long and laborious investigation is it able at length to contemplate with difficulty the invisible things of God, to discover and understand a First Cause and Author of all things. Christian philosophy, on the contrary, so quickens the human mind that without difficulty it pierces the heavens, and, illumined with divine light, contemplates first, the eternal source of light, and in its radiance all created things: so that we experience with the utmost pleasure of mind that we have been called, as the Prince of the Apostles says, out of darkness into his admirable light, and believing we rejoice with joy unspeakable. (1 Pet. 1:8; 1 Pet. 2:9)

Justly, therefore, do the faithful profess first to believe in God, whose majesty, with the Prophet Jeremias, we declare incomprehensible (Jer. 32:19). For, as the Apostle says, He dwells in light inaccessible, which no man hath seen, nor can see (1 Tim. 6:16); as God Himself, speaking to Moses, said: No man shall see my face and live (Exod. 33:20). The mind cannot rise to the contemplation of the Deity, whom nothing approaches in sublimity, unless it be entirely disengaged from the senses, and of this in the present life we art naturally incapable.*

Catechism of the Council of Trent

* On this question see Summa Theol. Ia. xii. 11.
On today's sharp division into mutually exclusive "objective" and "subjective" realms of knowledge and natural reason versus religion, faith, or "supernatural reason," respectively, Werner Heisenberg said:
I have to admit that I do not feel happy about this division. I doubt whether any human society can in the long term live with this sharp division between knowledge and faith. [...] Then Wolfgang Pauli took up the thread of the discussion and agreed with Heisenberg's doubt, asserting in fact that this was quite certain: "The complete division between knowledge and faith is surely just a temporary stopgap measure. In western society and culture we could for instance, in the not-too-distant future, come to the point at which the parables and images that religion has used up to now are not longer convincing even for simple folk; and then, I fear, traditional morality will also very rapidly break down, and things will happen that are more frightful than anything we can yet imagine."

—Pope Benedict XVI's Truth and Tolerance

Fortunately, faith and knowledge are not divided. Because all sciences ultimately point toward understanding God or "a First Cause and Author of all things"—and since God is "the truth," i.e., the absolute Truth (John 14:6)—St. Thomas Aquinas says:
We have a more perfect knowledge of God by grace than by natural reason. Which is proved thus. The knowledge which we have by natural reason contains two things: images derived from the sensible objects; and the natural intelligible light, enabling us to abstract from them intelligible conceptions. Now in both of these, human knowledge is assisted by the revelation of grace. For the intellect's natural light is strengthened by the infusion of gratuitous light.

Summa Theol. Ia. xii. 13, a comparison of faith and reason

Kurt Gödel's seminal 1931 paper On Formally Undecidable Propositions of Principia Mathematica and Related Systems showed that there are true propositions within formal mathematical systems that can neither be proven true nor false within their respective system. The propositions require something beyond—a sort of "faith" or outside means—to justify their truth. Thus mathematics, an invention of the human intellect, has its limitations. Similarly, the finite human mind has its limitations without the light of Divine Assistance, too—especially when it comes to understanding the Infinite, let alone the physical world.

It seems Pasteur, Heisenberg, Pauli, and Gödel all recognized the finitude of natural reason and its freedom to transcend when coupled with faith.

Tuesday, July 21, 2009

Virtuous Technology

The Catholic faith supports true science and technology, not "science [that] should trump ideology," e.g., not "science [that] should trump the Fifth Commandment, 'Thou shalt not kill.'" Therefore, true science and technology are virtuous, pro-life, and opposing of all "homicidal research." (Bishop Olmsted "What should science trump?")

Noah was humanity's first virtuous, pro-life scientist and engineer. Receiving scientific knowledge on how to build a piece of technology, a boat, not from himself but from the Holy Spirit, Wisdom; he saved humanity from destruction due to its poor decisions.
Noe found grace before the Lord. [...] the earth was corrupted before God, and was filled with iniquity. [...] [God] said to Noe: [...] Make thee an ark of timber planks: thou shalt make little rooms in the ark, and thou shalt pitch it within and without. And thus shalt thou make it. The length of the ark shall be three hundred cubits*: the breadth of it fifty cubits, and the height of it thirty cubits. Thou shalt make a window in the ark, and in a cubit shalt thou finish the top of it: and the door of the ark thou shalt set in the side: with lower, middle chambers, and third stories shalt thou make it. Behold, I will bring the waters of a great flood upon the earth [...]

Genesis 6:8,11,13-17

* 1 cubit ≈ 44 cm
Today, too, we face destruction due to our poor decisions regarding the sanctity of human life. Demography tells us that we are dying at an alarming rate. For example, the number of children ever born per woman living in the U.S. was 1.862 in 2006, much below the replacement level of 2.1; and 45.1% of U.S. women of fertile age have never had children (Fertility of American Women: 2006). Other countries, too, face economic problems due to aging populations, thus we are experiencing a "demographic winter." Pope Benedict XVI addresses the causes of this in his recent encyclical on economics, Caritas in Veritate.

Although there are many good research projects trying to save lives without killing other lives, there are also many that try to prevent or even kill human lives, as with contraceptive or abortifacient research, respectively. Like with Goethe's Faust, we have sold our souls for the exchange of scientific knowledge that compares very little to the greatness of Noah's science and technology, for God—"the guide of wisdom, and the director of the wise"—
hath given [us] the true knowledge of the things that are: to know the disposition of the whole world, and the virtues of the elements, the beginning, and ending, and midst of the times, the alterations of their courses, and the changes of seasons, the revolutions of the year, and the dispositions of the stars, the natures of living creatures, and rage of wild beasts, the force of winds, and reasonings of men, the diversities of plants, and the virtues of roots, and all such things as are hid, and not foreseen [...] For in [wisdom] is the spirit of understanding; holy, one, manifold, subtile, eloquent, active, undefiled, sure, sweet, loving that which is good, quick, which nothing hindereth, beneficent, gentle, kind, steadfast, assured, secure, having all power, overseeing all things, and containing all spirits: intelligible, pure, subtile.

Wisdom of Solomon 7:15,17-23

Pro-life technology is a great application of our intellect to helping others. Just as Noah applied his intellect to designing and building a boat to save humanity, so, too, can we apply ours to technology for our greater good, not death.